Rich Lowry

Back to: News
October 11, 2012
Follow News

LOWRY: Movie 'Won't Back Down' outrages teachers unions

Union protesters demonstrated outside the premiere of the new pro-education reform movie "Won't Back Down."

"'Won't Back Down,' get out of town" and "Move on over, corporate takeover," the protesters at the "Won't Back Down" premiere intoned. If their slogans were juvenile and the instincts thuggish, the calculation of their self-interest was exactly right - unions shouldn't want anyone to see this film.

In an outraged public letter, the head of the American Federation of Teachers, Randi Weingarten, complained that the movie traffics in "the most blatant stereotypes and caricatures I have ever seen." Really? Weingarten must never have seen a World War II movie, or a film featuring a hooker with a heart of gold, or pretty much any romantic comedy.

What makes "Won't Back Down" so objectionable to her isn't that its characters are stereotypes but that they are revelations. Time-serving teachers beholden to a union obsessed with its prerogatives and power don't often show up on the big screen, or we'd hear about more union pickets of movie openings.

"Won't Back Down" is about a plucky working-class mother played by Maggie Gyllenhaal whose dyslexic daughter is "getting crushed," as she puts it, at the awful local elementary school. She enlists a teacher at the school, played by Viola Davis, to work with her to trigger a parent-teacher takeover of the failing school. A great contest between the reforming duo and the powers that be ensues, and - I'm probably not spoiling it for anyone if I reveal this - the duo prevails.

The villain in "Won't Back Down" is the system, with the union playing an outsize role in it. That makes it a more complex portrayal of education than the typical classroom movie that celebrates the heroic efforts of one teacher. The teachers in "Won't Back Down" are burdened by a lackluster principal, a deadening culture of mediocrity at their school, and their fear of losing their union protections when presented with the possibility of something new.

If all she cares about is the depiction of the teachers in the movie, Weingarten should be pleased. Many of them - after agonizing over their loyalty to the union and considerations of their own interest - decide to do the right thing and support a radical reform of their atrocious school.

The chief producer of the film, Walden Media, has an interest in promoting educational change. It's a sign of the times, though, that Maggie Gyllenhaal and Viola Davis broadly support the film's message. Davis said of the protesters, "There was not one person - I guarantee you - that was outside there protesting with a picket sign who had their child in a failing school."

In one scene in "Won't Back Down," a union official with a history of union organizing in her family asks plaintively, "When did Norma Rae become the bad guy?" When she became a cog in a union machine that protects an educational system that everyone knows isn't working. "Won't Back Down" may make Randi Weingarten angry, but it mostly should make her afraid for her cause.

Rich Lowry is editor of the National Review, a magazine founded by William F. Buckley Jr., featuring conservative commentary on American politics.


Explore Related Articles

The Post Independent Updated Oct 11, 2012 04:14PM Published Oct 11, 2012 04:12PM Copyright 2012 The Post Independent. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.