Elk Mountains are in a league of their own for risk | PostIndependent.com
Scott Condon
The Aspen Times

Back to: Crime

Elk Mountains are in a league of their own for risk

Capitol Peak is considered one of the toughest hikes among Colorado's mountains over 14,000 feet in elevation, but some of its neighbors in Pitkin County remain more deadly.

Two hikers have died at different places under different circumstances on Capitol Peak this summer, so experts note that there's no single factor that can be pinpointed for the tragedies.

"The bottom line is none of the Elks is easy, and all of them have inherent risks," said Lloyd Athearn, executive director of the Colorado Fourteeners Initiative, a nonprofit that works to preserve the big peaks.

Hikers and climbers face a number of objective and subjective factors affecting their outings, he said. Subjective factors are ones they can control — such as getting an early start to minimize hiking when storms are more likely and having the skills and experience to complete a technical route. Objective factors cannot be controlled — such as loose rock giving way.

Some of the more technical routes in Colorado's 14ers exist in the Elk Range. Castle Peak and Conundrum Peak are easier to scale and haven't proven statistically likely for incidents, but Maroon Peak, North Maroon Peak, Pyramid Peak, Snowmass Mountain (the 14er not the ski area) and Capitol Peak have proven to be among the most treacherous for incidents and fatalities, Athearn said.

He has studied the incidents and fatalities from 2000 through 2015 in the Elk Mountains using records from the Pitkin County Sheriff's Office and Mountain Rescue Aspen and articles from The Aspen Times. Though he tried to document all incidents, it might not be comprehensive, he said.

Recommended Stories For You

"The Maroon Bells would be twice as likely, statistically, to have an accident or a death," Athearn said, referring to the findings.

There were 20 climbing incidents on the Maroon Bells and eight deaths over that 16-year period. There were three additional non-climber deaths, when people were killed in the area when their primary activity wasn't bagging a peak. For example, a hunter fell to his death while tracking mountain goats.

The Maroon Bells accounted for 42 percent of all incidents and 42 percent of the climbing deaths in the Elks, according to Athearn's research.

Over that same period, Capitol Peak logged 10 climber incidents and four deaths. That doesn't include the two fatalities this year or any incidents in 2016.

Capitol Peak stands out among the Colorado 14ers because of the exposure near the mountaintop.

"We would put that at the top as far as difficulty in the state," said Scott Robson, executive director of the Colorado Mountain Club, which promotes adventure, safety and environmental protection of the peaks.

The Knife Edge, where the latest fatal mishap occurred Sunday, has extreme exposure and a lengthy drop on both sides, as the name suggests.

"You really are on your butt scooting along for some time," Robson said. "Once you're committed, you're really at the mercy of the weather."

He estimated the length of the Knife Edge at about one-third of a mile, but that isn't the issue. It's the exposure and the difficulty of crossing it.

"Distance doesn't really make a difference at that point," he said.

The exposure and long distance make it among the areas on Colorado 14ers that are truly a "no-fall zone," Robson said.

Ted Mahon, an Aspenite who has climbed and skied all the Colorado 14ers and accomplished various mountaineering feats in summer as well, said Capitol is just steep enough to put it in its own category.

"There are places (on other peaks and on lower Capitol) where you could fall and just get scraped up," he said. But falling at the Knife Edge and other places on the peak result in death.

"I feel Capitol has more than one trouble spot," he said.

He warns against trying to pigeonhole the mountain in any specific way. Accidents occur because of different circumstances at different times.

"It's wrong to say Capitol is 'fill-in-the-blank,'" Mahon said.

Glenwood Climbing Guides owner Mike Schneiter has taught climbing for 17 years. He identified several challenges to climbing Capitol. It's a longer journey than many — 17 miles round-trip — and many people will break it into two days. Even when he leads a group to Capitol Lake and plans for a day-two summit, Schneiter advises groups to plan for 10 hours from camp to summit and back again.

"That fatigue and exhaustion causes problems for people," he said. "I see it all the time: People get fumbly and can't move as well when they're tired."

Snow is another issue. Many people attempt Capitol when there's less snow, but Schneiter said it's actually safer when snow covers the peak. That's because snow reduces the amount of loose rock a climber faces. Route finding and exposure also add to the peak's difficulty.

"It's a good one to work up to. People need to be sure they're experienced and feel comfortable, and if they're not, hire a guide," said Schneiter, who also works with Aspen Alpine Guides and Colorado Mountain School.

Robson said many hikers leave Capitol to the end of their list of 14ers, with good reason. They should get experience in technical hiking before tackling Capitol and a handful of other peaks. Unfortunately, others try to hike it before they have the proper skills and experience. There's pressure to tackle the 14ers.

All of the hiking and climbing experts stressed that they were talking in general terms and not specific incidents, such as the fatal accident Sunday.

"They are a tick list and a magnet to those who want to climb 14ers," Robson said of the Elk Mountains. "There's definitely a summit fever that sets in. It's real.

"People give it a run. Most people make it," he added.

Athearn said Colorado Fourteeners Initiative doesn't have specific data on use of Capitol Peak. The nonprofit organization has placed people counters on some of Colorado's highest mountains, but the U.S. Forest Service doesn't allow the mechanized tools in wilderness, where most of the 14ers are located.

In general, hiker numbers are up from 10 years ago and substantially higher than four decades ago, but there's no evidence of single-year spikes, he said.

As the number of people on the big peaks increases, it stands to reason that there are going to be more accidents, Mahon said. It doesn't mean the slopes are suddenly more dangerous.

Increased use has created some advantages. The loose rock has been kicked off many of the routes, Mahon and Athearn noted.

Robson said there is no reason to be unprepared with all the online resources. However, that might not be enough.

"You can be armed with a high degree of technical knowledge," he said, "but once you're standing on that Knife ridge, it all goes out the window."

Despite the exposure of the Knife Edge, most hikers don't use climbing ropes to secure themselves along that section. Many don't feel it's necessary. Others don't want to take the time. Guiding services in the Aspen area often use the short rope technique, where hikers on either side of the ridge are tied to one another.

"The local guide services in town will rope up clients every time," Mahon said.

Neither Colorado Mountain Club nor Colorado Fourteeners Initiative necessarily promotes use of ropes. They promote safety and preparation.

Athearn said hikers can take many steps to reduce the risk — go with someone experienced, go when the weather is favorable, pick your time carefully and accept if you have to turn around without bagging the peak.

"A big part of it is humility," he said, "and realizing these mountains are unforgiving."

Glenwood Springs Post Independent features editor Carla Jean Whitley contributed to this report.

INCIDENTS IN THE ELKS

Since 2000, six people have died on Capitol Peak, including four in the past five years. Two men have died in the past month on the climbing the 14,131-foot peak. According to data from the Colorado Fourteeners Initiative, 19 climbers died in the Elk Mountains from 2000-2015:

Mountain Deaths

Maroon Bells 8

Pyramid Peak 2

Capitol Peak 4*

Snowmass Mountain 5

Castle/Conundrum Peak 0

*-does not include two in 2017

A look at the recent deaths on Capitol Peak (according to Aspen Times reports):

2003

Name, age, town unavailable: On May 8, a climber was caught in a rockslide on the west face of the mountain from the false summit K2. His partner reported the man fell 300 feet.

http://www.aspentimes.com/news/climber-killed-on-capitol” target=”_blank”>Text”>http://www.aspentimes.com/news/climber-killed-on-capitol/

2009

Jimi Flowers, 47, Colorado Springs: Authorities believe he fell at about 13,000 feet, on the east side of the ridge between K2 and Daly saddle while on the descent during a July 11 climb with another man.

http://www.aspentimes.com/news/climber-in-fatal-fall-identified” target=”_blank”>Text”>http://www.aspentimes.com/news/climber-in-fatal-fall-identified/

2013

Ryan Palmer, 35, Vail: He fell 200 to 300 feet on the north face of Capitol Peak on July 21 and his body was located two days later. Got separated from two hiking partners.

http://www.aspentimes.com/news/vail-hiker-idd-recovered-from-capitol-peak-outside-of-aspen” target=”_blank”>Text”>http://www.aspentimes.com/news/vail-hiker-idd-recovered-from-capitol-peak-outside-of-aspen/

2014

Jim Nelson, 53, Salt Lake City: His family reported him overdue Aug. 5 and he was climbing alone. His body was found a day later in Mount Daly Basin above Moon Lake.

http://www.aspentimes.com/news/climbers-body-found-near-capitol-peak” target=”_blank”>Text”>http://www.aspentimes.com/news/climbers-body-found-near-capitol-peak/

2017

Jake Lord, 25, Parker: He was climbing July 15 with another man and fell nearly 300 feet when a boulder came loose on the ridge between Capitol and Mount Daly.

http://www.aspentimes.com/news/deputy-loose-boulder-caused-capitol-peak-climbers-fall” target=”_blank”>Text”>http://www.aspentimes.com/news/deputy-loose-boulder-caused-capitol-peak-climbers-fall/

Male, 35, Front Range: A yet-to-be identified man died Sunday after falling from the Knife’s Edge near the summit. He was with a group.