Amendments Y and Z aiming to make redistricting less political |

Amendments Y and Z aiming to make redistricting less political

Frances Hohl
Steamboat Pilot & Today

The Glenwood Springs Post Independent, in conjunction with other Colorado Mountain News Media group newspapers, is running a series of stories on the statewide measures that are on the Nov. 6 ballot. These stories are intended to help explain the ballot questions, and will be running before the election. Ballots will be mailed out the week of Oct. 15.

Colorado may have found a way to make drawing up congressional and legislative districts almost non-political, and now it’s up to voters statewide to decide whether they want to test the theory.

Amendments Y and Z on the state ballot have earned the endorsement of Colorado’s Democratic and Republican parties, and the measures aim to give Colorado independents a voice in redistricting.

The goal of the amendments is to draw up districts based on the population’s commonalities and not solely on political affiliation.

Rep. Dylan Roberts, a Democrat serving House District 26 in Routt and Eagle counties, said Y covers congressional redistricting and Z covers legislative redistricting within the state.

“My state house is probably not gerrymandered that much,” explained Roberts, an Eagle County assistant district attorney who co-sponsored the amendments. “Routt and Eagle have a lot in common, so there’s sort of a natural fit together with the right population size for a district.

“But you go to U.S. Congressional District 3 … Routt County is in the same congressional district as Pueblo and Grand Junction and Montrose and the San Luis Valley,” Roberts said. “We don’t necessarily have a lot in common with those counties. Economically, culturally, we have more in common with Larimer County, Boulder County and Summit counties. If these amendments pass, you might see Routt County grouped with a more natural fit when it comes to the U.S. Congress.”

Fair Maps Colorado is the group that got the amendments on the ballot after two different political groups were trying it on their own.

“We set aside any differences we had in favor of a policy that would be good for Colorado … a model system that would really take this process out of the hands of political insiders and put it in the hands of voters,” Fair Maps Colorado spokesman Curtis Hubbard said.

Currently, state legislative districts are overseen by a commission of four legislative leaders, three appointees from the governor and four appointees from the chief justice of the Colorado Supreme Court.

Hubbard claims the current system favors political insiders, leaves out unaffiliated voters and makes a lot of districts non-competitive.

“We’ll be the first state in the U.S. to give unaffiliated voters a seat at the table in redistricting measures,” Hubbard said.

Amendments Y and Z propose a commission made up of four Republicans, four Democrats and four unaffiliated members, with half chosen by lottery and half chosen by a panel of retired judges.

“Any map has to be approved by a super majority of eight votes of the 12 commissioners, and that has to include two of the unaffiliated voters,” Hubbard said.

Hubbard said the amendments include limits on the role of politicians and lobbyists and requires public hearings in each congressional district.

Roberts said redistricting, based on populations that fit in culturally, economically and socioeconomically, will naturally make legislative and congressional districts more competitive.

“Out of seven districts in Colorado, only one of them is really competitive election to election” and that’s U.S. Congressional District 6, Roberts said. “Right now, our congressman (Republican Scott Tipton) is from Cortez. He has to represent Pueblo to Grand Junction to Steamboat and a lot of different interests.”

Tipton also represents Garfield and Pitkin counties.

Roberts said he believes the new redistricting rules would lead to representatives who care more about their constituents than their parties.

“If an area of the state has a lot in common, they’re going to want a Congress person who understands their issues deeply and can advocate for them in Washington, D.C.

“I support Y and Z because once an elected official is in office, they have to represent a district that’s more fairly drawn based off of economics and region and culture, not just political party,” Roberts added.

For more information on Amendments Y and Z, visit

Support Local Journalism

Support Local Journalism

Readers around Glenwood Springs and Garfield County make the Post Independent’s work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.

Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.

Each donation will be used exclusively for the development and creation of increased news coverage.