Caloia to challenge Beeson in 9th DA race |

Caloia to challenge Beeson in 9th DA race

Heather McGregor
Post Independent Editor
Glenwood Springs, CO Colorado

GLENWOOD SPRINGS, Colorado – Local attorney Sherry Caloia, a Democrat, announced late Tuesday that she will challenge Ninth District Attorney Martin Beeson in the November election.

“I was looking to do something new with new challenges. I feel I am very qualified,” said Caloia, 56, of Glenwood Springs. (Her name is pronounced ka-loy-ah.)

“Also, I am unhappy with many things going on with the DA’s office,” she said. “I have done some defense work, and I have seen and heard about many cases that have been prosecuted that are questionable.”

Caloia said the district attorney’s office must use discretion to decide whether or not a case should go forward. Once a case is seen as legal and provable, prosecutors still need to “use prosecutorial discretion,” she said, and decide whether a case should go forward.

“Many criminal cases are being set for trial. This is because of ill will toward defense attorneys. Meanwhile, civil trials are being put on the back burner because the courts are so crowded,” Caloia said.

Caloia said her platform as a candidate will center on keeping an open line of communication with defense attorneys, disclosing case information to defense attorneys, and making sure the office doesn’t overcharge cases.

“I’m not going to brag about how many hours of jail time I got in a year. We want defendants to not come back to court, so however that gets done is the way it should be done,” she said.

Caloia is a private practice attorney who also serves as the prosecuting attorney for Carbondale and Basalt municipal courts. She started her law career as a deputy district attorney in Adams County.

In between, she has worked in the state Attorney General’s office on water rights cases, and in the Garfield County Attorney’s office handling cases of abused and neglected children. She also served as a contract attorney with the county enforcing child support orders.

She has served as the town attorney for Eagle, Marble and Palisade, and has handled some municipal law duties for Carbondale and Basalt.

Beeson, a Rifle Republican, applauded Caloia Wednesday for “having the courage to get in the ring.”

But he immediately attacked her level of experience in prosecuting felony cases.

“Prosecuting parking tickets and barking dogs in municipal court is not comparable to trying murder cases in criminal court. You can’t make that leap without the proper training and know-how,” he said.

“It appears her primary issue is with my prosecutorial philosophy, which is to be tough on crime and seek justice for victims. When we have sufficient evidence to prosecute, we do so,” he added.

Beeson said his office reaches a resolution in most criminal cases without taking them to trial, and at a rate comparable to district attorneys throughout the state.

“But where the rubber meets the road is with prosecuting serious, violent crimes, and she has not enough experience in it. This is a very serious decision for the electorate to make,” Beeson said.

Democrats in the Ninth Judicial District, meanwhile, contend that Beeson is not eligible to run for re-election, arguing that his three years in office from 2006 through 2008 serving out the term of recalled District Attorney Colleen Truden counts as a term.

Caloia said she has heard that some defense attorneys in the Ninth District may mount a formal challenge to Beeson’s candidacy. She said she agrees, but she won’t be joining them.

“I don’t think I will have time,” she said. “But if people have said they don’t want politicians serving more than two terms, then they should look at Martin Beeson, who is running for a third term.”

Beeson contends that an opinion issued in 2000 by then-Attorney General Ken Salazar supports his ability to run for a second full four-year term. The opinion states that term limits “have no application to partial terms of office, but rather apply only to full terms.”

The Ninth Judicial District encompasses Rio Blanco, Garfield and Pitkin counties. The district attorney’s office presently has 35 staff members spread among offices in Meeker, Rifle, Glenwood Springs and Aspen.

Support Local Journalism

Support Local Journalism

Readers around Glenwood Springs and Garfield County make the Post Independent’s work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.

Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.

Each donation will be used exclusively for the development and creation of increased news coverage.


Start a dialogue, stay on topic and be civil.
If you don't follow the rules, your comment may be deleted.

User Legend: iconModerator iconTrusted User