Harvey Gap results show difficulties fighting coal seam fires | PostIndependent.com

Harvey Gap results show difficulties fighting coal seam fires

Editor’s note: This is the second in a two-part series. The first, which ran Tuesday, reported on plans by the state to try to fight a coal seam fire in South Canyon that ignited a destructive wildfire in 2002.Results of a 2003 project north of Silt reflect the challenges of fighting underground fires along the Grand Hogback.Efforts to seal off airways to a fire near Harvey Gap Reservoir have resulted in general cooling of the fire, said Steve Renner, project manager for the Division of Minerals and Geology’s inactive mines program.But the project also revealed that there are probably multiple coal seams and multiple mines at the site, Renner said. He said he wouldn’t be surprised if the project failed to reach all the burning areas.Mac Burnett, of Rifle, who worked as a contractor on the project, said crews poured a million gallons of water and 40 truckloads of grout into the underground fires.Such fires are typically hard to put out, he said. At Harvey Gap, some parts of the mine cooled down quite a bit, and another part still has 900-degree gas coming out.”We ran out of money before we could finish that site,” he said. “If you put enough money on something like that you probably can solve it, but it’s really expensive to put that kind of material in a mine.”Renner said his program gets only about $2 million a year, through federal grants, and there are 23,000 abandoned mines statewide. The top priority is preventing people from getting killed around the mines by putting up signs, fencing and other protection.Fires are a high priority, too. But Renner said he could spend his entire budget for inactive mines just fighting a couple of fires. And there would be no guarantee of success.”There’s no right answer on these fires,” Renner said.The state has fought a fire at the IHI Mine east of Rifle Gap off and on for 20 years, Renner noted. It’s still burning, although the state had some success containing it in the mid 1990s in a project that cost about $875,000.One trick with the Grand Hogback fires is that they are associated with mines that generally were dug at the base of the formation. The miners dug fingers upward into the mountain to bring coal down. This created natural chimneys to fissures reaching the surface up above, which allows fires to vent and draft.”It’s very conducive to fires,” Renner said.Part of the work at places such as Harvey Gap involves simply trying to understand the mining, and what kind of collapsing and venting occurred after the mining stopped, Renner said.Treatments can vary. Foam might be injected to try to cool a fire. A cement grout is used to try to seal off air supplies.Said Burnett, “We’re all still searching for a really good method, and a good method really needs to be inexpensive because there’s so many fires they get really expensive.”It can be hard to know immediately what kind of effect treatments such as the one at Harvey Gap have on fires.”They’re kind of cyclical in nature,” Renner said. “They’ll burn really hot and settle down and hot and settle down by kind of the nature of what goes on underground.”

Support Local Journalism

Support Local Journalism

Readers around Glenwood Springs and Garfield County make the Post Independent’s work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.

Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.

Each donation will be used exclusively for the development and creation of increased news coverage.


Start a dialogue, stay on topic and be civil.
If you don't follow the rules, your comment may be deleted.

User Legend: iconModerator iconTrusted User