Polman column: Halloween costumes: Free expression vs. offense
Everything is offensive now — even Halloween.
In Sandy Springs, Ga., a fellow’s humorous display featured a pumpkin man mooning the street.
“His pants are halfway down, showing his backside which is made up of pumpkins,” reports CBS12.com.
Neighbors complained to their homeowner’s association that the display was offensive, so the fellow altered it.
Which is regrettable.
Halloween is — or used to be, anyhow — a time for stressed-out adults to blow off a little steam and have a little fun.
Long a staple of childhood, Halloween in the past few decades increasingly has been celebrated by adults — for good reason.
Eleven years ago, when Halloween’s popularity among adults was rapidly growing, Robert Thompson, Newhouse Director of the Bleier Center for Television and Popular Culture at Syracuse University, explained why.
“It’s the one day where almost anything goes,” Thompson told me in 2008. “Adults can be a wise guy or do something outrageous they’d never do normally.”
Thompson said adults generally picked costumes that mocked or satirized popular culture. In my opinion, nothing is healthier for a well-functioning society than the ability to freely and heartily mock things we find silly.
Such free expression is under attack in some quarters.
Several publications are pointing out costumes to avoid because they may offend someone.
Good Housekeeping suggests avoiding Holocaust-victim costumes — though for the life of me, I don’t know why anyone would want to sport a costume like that.
But last year, Good Housekeeping says, “several retailers came under fire for selling an ‘Anne Frank’ costume for little girls.”
I scratch my head at the stupidity of my fellow human beings who came up with an Anne Frank costume — but the idiotic retailers who stocked them quickly pulled them off their shelves.
Hitler and Nazi costumes are out. A Marie Claire story mentions the hullabaloo in 2005 over Prince Harry going to a party dressed as a Nazi.
But wasn’t the point of that costume to mock and berate the followers of the evil mastermind who plunged the world into a horrendous war and created the Holocaust? Wasn’t that costume meant to remind us that we must never forget the evil that some humans are capable of, and that we must be ever-vigilant in preventing it from ever happening again?
Any costume displaying blackface is out this year, which is obvious to everyone — except the fools, no doubt, who aspire to political office.
Costumes that play off animal cruelty, eating disorders and mentally illness are out, too — though again, aside from some idiotic retailers, I can’t think of anyone foolish enough to target such subjects.
Zombie costumes are out — if one dresses up as a zombie version of a recently deceased celebrity. Why? Because, says Good Housekeeping, “a dead — or undead, a.k.a. zombie — version brings to mind the phrase ‘too soon.’”
Look: On one hand, it’s good for adults to be mindful enough to avoid offending others with their Halloween costumes.
On the other hand, it’s dangerous to limit free expression in a free and open society.
Satire may not always be pleasant — a bold satirist always risks crossing the line — but it plays an important role.
The free expression of ideas — the freedom of anyone in our society to mock politics and popular culture as they see fit — is the lifeblood of a well-functioning republic.
May the pumpkin man’s mooning commence!
Send comments to Tom at Tom@TomPurcell.com.
Support Local Journalism
Support Local Journalism
Readers around Glenwood Springs and Garfield County make the Post Independent’s work possible. Your financial contribution supports our efforts to deliver quality, locally relevant journalism.
Now more than ever, your support is critical to help us keep our community informed about the evolving coronavirus pandemic and the impact it is having locally. Every contribution, however large or small, will make a difference.
Each donation will be used exclusively for the development and creation of increased news coverage.
Start a dialogue, stay on topic and be civil.
If you don't follow the rules, your comment may be deleted.
User Legend: Moderator Trusted User
A strong feeling of hopelessness in the future has pervaded the faith of many Americans in the future of our democracy. This is evident from the flocking of support for the demagogue, Donald Trump, in…